Friday, April 18, 2014

Why Good Friday is Too Often Like a Bad Indiana Jones Movie

The Problem: The Math of It All
I don't know why this is, but the older I get, the less I find myself able to accept the way that the Church generally talks about the death of Jesus.  More specifically, this sense that "Jesus died for our sins".

It's not that I'm squeamish. It's the math of it all.  Jesus dies = We are saved.

By the calculus of the ancient world, that makes sense. Gods are appeased through violence. The stability of society is reinforced. Jesus takes the place in Jewish tradition of the lamb.

But in our world, that makes no sense at all. Murder does not save. Indeed, as the great philosopher Rene Girard has written about, the cross reveals the lie of that idea, because it shows the brutality at the heart of such a philosophy. It displays the victim.

As far as I can tell, the way that Christianity has avoided dealing with this is by saying we're talking God here -- God sacrificing his son, God being willing to be sacrificed for us. Human logic does not apply.

But what kind of a God is okay with human sacrifice? I suspect, not one would we would hope to meet when we die.

And the other thing is, this equation is EXACTLY human logic. As we just said, it's humans that for millennia have killed animals, adults, even children out of a sense that it would save them.

This should make us very suspicious.

And frankly I think many of us live aware that this is a problem, aware that this idea that Jesus died to save us from our sins or that God was cool with Christ being whacked doesn't really make sense. Not really. And yet it's not a deal breaker -- we never really believed in that Old Testament figure of wrath and violence anyway -- and we're not theologians, so we just let it sit there.

But it should be a deal breaker for us. We should not accept a concept of God like this, or let our children be taught to think that God is like this. Because we deserve better. Indeed, the story of our salvation in both Old and New Testaments is a story of God rescuing humanity from precisely such notions and societies. And even when necessary rescuing them from himself!

The Solution: A Faithful (not Wrathful) God 
So on a day like today, who do I see up there on the cross? Not the solution to a math equation. But a man, God become flesh, who came among us because he saw how much we were in need, how hungry and confused and sad we were, and wanted to be the light that would shine in our darkness, illuminate the Lord who loves us, and help us on our way.

And of course, OF COURSE, that was threatening to people. People in power, but also just the rank and file. It was as true then as it is now: If you really want to scare somebody, tell them that you love them. 

And so of course, eventually, some of them wanted him dead. And he could have run from that. Or just stopped being so damn challenging.

But that meant stepping away from the people, both the ones who knew they were hungry for hope and kindness and looked to him for help, and the ones who were just as hungry or even more and didn't know it, whose pain was pushed back behind their rage and condemnation.

And that's not who Jesus was. That's not who God is. So he kept on going, even though it looked like it would not end well.

And it did not end well. In fact, it ended in pretty much the most horrific way possible, not just killed, but publicly humiliated and left to die as mocking bystanders watched. It ended so badly Jesus even doubted whether he had been right about what he believed about God and himself all along.

The Nutshell
What saves us is not that Jesus died for us. It's that God is faithful to us. So faithful that he came down to earth to be with us; that he refused to run away from us when threatened (by some of us); and that when he died as a man, God raised him up.

It's a package deal, the crucifixion and resurrection. Together they express the same truth -- that God  does not give up on us. That he is faithful to us.

And we shouldn't let anyone tell us different.


aremonstrantsramblings said...

You say: "What saves us is not that Jesus died for us." And you don't think anyone should tell us differently. What about the NT then? Are you distancing yourself from what the NT says? Do you know God better than the NT? Does it not concern you ever so slightly that most Christians have understood the cross this way? Does it not give you a moment of pause to consider that most scholars agree that the NT has some legal understanding of what took place on the cross? I think it ought to.

aremonstrantsramblings said...

I wrote a response:

danny cull said...

Why are you deceived? as sin came by one man, Adam and all have sinned, and the only way to be free and clean from sin is believing and followed by repentance, the blood of Jesus is applied to the door post of your heart and all your sins are washed away and forgiven, all of the old testament told of his coming, and all the slaughtered animal sacrifices were showing us what he would have to go through and do to save us from sin and it's bondage and blindness. it is finished - the moment Christ died - Satan became powerless against the blood of Jesus and the gates of hell and the bondage of sin is destroyed, God told us Jesus was coming and he would be slaughtered for us because without Jesus going to the cross and suffering and dyeing for us, God was going to send us all to hell right then and there. Jesus said i can call to God and he'll send 10,000 angels to rescue me from this; but love kept Jesus here and God gave him strength to go through all this for us. had Jesus called God save me, you and I and all humanity would be looking up in a real living eternal hell right now. Jesus was beaten, torn, slaughtered for your sins. and for my sins. believe and repent and be saved and get to know the real and only Jesus the Son of the only living God. and have a lil talk with Jesus and he'll show you everything if you only believe repent and follow him, and you need baptism of the Holy Ghost to to see and understand the Spirit World of God.